2014 Indiana Homeowners Insurance Complaint Index

NAIC # Company Name Premium Number Index
1 33898 Aegis Security Insurance Company 728,542 1 DNC
2 19240 Allstate Indemnity Company 2,498,961 2 19.71
3 19232 Allstate Insurance Company 45,755,099 4 2.15
4 17230 Allstate Property And Casualty Insurance Company 58,431,436 5 2.11
5 19275 American Family Mutual Insurance Company 81,690,022 4 1.21
6 38652 American Modern Select Insurance Company 5,188,327 1 4.75
7 19992 American Select Insurance Company 6,245,114 1 3.94
8 10052 Chubb National Insurance Company 7,680,181 1 3.21
9 29734 Conifer Insurance Company 4,560,272 1 5.40
10 40649 Economy Premier Assurance Company 1,393,820 1 17.67
11 22292 Hanover Insurance Company 1,171 1 DNC
12 13927 Homesite Insurance Company of the Midwest 18,528,214 2 2.66
13 22624 Indiana Farmers Mutual Insurance Company 45,541,821 1 0.54
14 42404 Liberty Insurance Corporation 11,949,914 1 2.06
15 33600 LM Insurance Corporation 11,019,915 1 2.23
16 23043 Liberty Mutual Insurance Company None 1 DNC
17 21229 MemberSelect Insurance Company 10,050,059 1 2.45
18 23353 Meridian Security Insurance Company 13,528,349 1 1.82
19 14621 Motorists Mutual Insurance Company 6,307,467 1 3.90
20 23779 Nationwide Mutual Fire Insurance Company 18,676,418 1 1.32
21 32700 Owners Insurance Company 26,433,189 3 2.80
22 32905 Property-Owners Insurance Company 23,933,789 1 1.03
23 11000 Sentinel Insurance Company, Ltd. 1,625,531 1 15.15
24 25143 State Farm Fire and Casualty Company 484,909,595 27 1.37
25 25178 State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company None 1 DNC
26 40118 Trustgard Insurance Company 11,905,377 2 4.14
27 15288 United Farm Family Mutual Insurance Company 137,742,927 4 0.72
28 44393 West American Insurance Company (35,270) 1 DNC
Subtotal Premium and Complaints 1,036,290,240 72
162 Companies with Zero Complaints 737,032,294  
Total Premium and Complaints 1,773,322,534 72
Report does not include 162 companies with zero complaints
DNC- did not calculate (premiums under $1 million)
None – No premium was reported during 2014.
Premium information from Property & Casualty Annual Statement Page 19, Line 4, Column 1

The information contained in this table is based on figures published by the Indiana Department of Insurance on its website.  “Number” in the table above refers to the number of complaints as published by the IDOI.

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: